Are you unsure between a home birth or a hospital birth? Summarised here are the main differences in terms of tranquillity, privacy, stress and control over your environment:

Privacy: At home, you decide who is there and have complete control. In hospital, there are changing caregivers and less privacy.
Rest: At home, you enjoy a familiar and quiet environment. In hospital, noises and routines can be disruptive.
Control: At home, you can adjust everything from lighting to temperature. In the hospital, you are tied to standard facilities.
Stress: At home, you have a permanent obstetrician and more freedom of movement. In the hospital, protocols and unfamiliar faces can cause extra tension.

Quick comparison table

Aspect	Home birth	Hospital birth
Privacy	Full control	Changing caregivers
Rest	Own familiar space	Regular disruptions
Environmental control	Customisable	Limited options
Stress	Less by fixed care	More by protocols

Want to know more about how these choices affect your birthing experience? Read on for a detailed comparison.

Home birth vs Hospital birth | Advantages & Disadvantages

Privacy: Home vs hospital

The choice between the familiar environment of home and the organised structure of the hospital has a major impact on privacy during labour.

Privacy benefits of Home

In a home birth, parents have full control over who is present and when. This creates an intimate atmosphere where partners can be together without interruptions. The space can be used completely as desired, and healthcare providers adapt their support to the natural course of labour.

In addition, the private bathroom and bedroom offer direct access and privacy, without having to share them. This gives women the freedom to move comfortably and adopt different postures without feeling that they are being watched. Practices such as Verloskundig Huis Lief Leven emphasise this autonomy with a personalised approach and respect for parents' wishes.

In a hospital, however, the situation is different.

Privacy in the Hospital

In a hospital, there are naturally more restrictions on privacy. Different healthcare providers alternate, and check-ups are carried out at set times. Medical staff can come in at any time for routine checks or handovers. Rooms are often smaller and filled with medical equipment.

Although modern hospitals pay increasing attention to improving privacy, it is still a shared environment. Sounds from other rooms may be audible, and protocols and routines affect the level of quiet and seclusion.

Privacy Compare: Home and Hospital

Privacy aspect	Home birth	Hospital birth
Control over environment	Full	Restricted
Access to space	Only desired persons	Changing care staff
Freedom of movement	Entire house available	Limited to delivery room
Sanitary facilities	Private	Shared or partly private
Noise pollution	Minimum	Possible from other rooms
Visitor policy	Self-defined	According to hospital rules
Length of stay	Flexible	According to protocol

Stress and Rest levels

Stress, like privacy, plays a major role in how childbirth is experienced. A safe and familiar environment helps reduce stress and supports the natural course of birth.

Benefits of Home Birth for Rest

Giving birth at home offers an environment that promotes calm and relaxation. You are in your own familiar space, where you can move freely and choose your own spot to relax. Consider using personal items such as your favourite music, scents or comfortable cushions, all of which contribute to a sense of security.

In addition, the presence of a permanent midwife is a great advantage. This ensures continuity of care and eliminates the stress of changing faces. Without time pressure or unnecessary disruptions, the birth process can proceed naturally.

Stress factors in a Hospital environment

A hospital, on the other hand, can bring stressful situations. The unfamiliar environment, often filled with medical equipment, can create tension. Strict protocols and frequent check-ups can disrupt moments of calm, and changing healthcare providers can affect the sense of continuity.

Common stressors in hospitals:

Restricted movement due to use of monitors and infusions
Disturbing sounds and signals from medical equipment
Less control over things like lighting and room temperature

Comparison of Stress Factors

Aspect	Home birth	Hospital birth
Healthcare providers	Regular midwife	Changing team
Environmental control	Full ownership	Limited possibilities
Time pressure	Natural pace	Protocols and schedules
Comfort items	Unlimited availability	Limited carry
Freedom of movement	Complete freedom	Often limited by equipment
Rest moments	Self-defined	Depending on care plan
Stress reduction	Own methods possible	According to hospital policy

This comparison shows how the environment can affect stress levels and thus the childbirth experience.

sbb-itb-d10c62c

Noise and disturbances

Besides privacy and stress, noise control plays a big role in how childbirth is experienced.

Sound control at home

At home, you are in control of the sounds around you. You decide what you hear and what you don't. The familiar sounds of your own home are often less disturbing than the unexpected sounds in a hospital. This control over the sound environment contributes to a sense of security, just as privacy and tranquillity do.

Benefits of noise control at home:

You can play your own music at the volume you like.
You have control over ambient sounds such as phones and the doorbell.
External noises you can limit.
The acoustics of your home are often more pleasant.

Sound problems at the Hospital

In a hospital, there are many sounds that you cannot influence. These noises can cause stress. As it is, the medical environment brings more noise pollution.

Common noise sources in the hospital:

Beeps from monitors and other medical equipment.
Noise from adjacent rooms and corridors.
Announcements via intercom.
Care staff walking in and out.
Conversations in the corridor.
Trolleys and beds driving by.

These differences become clear in the table below.

Comparison of Noise Levels

Disturbance type	Home birth	Hospital birth
Background noise	Familiar house sounds	Continuous hospital sounds
Medical equipment	Minimum presence	Regular beeps and signals
External disturbances	Self regulating	Unaffected
Voice	Familiar voices	Unidentified voices and conversations
Door open/close	Limited to own choice	Regularly by healthcare providers
Nightly rest	Natural silence	Ongoing hospital activity
Music and atmosphere	Completely your own choice	Limited possibilities

The noise level during childbirth can have a great impact on the comfort and stress level of the woman giving birth. At home, you usually have more control over your sound environment, while in the hospital you are dependent on the sounds and routines that are part of the care environment there.

Setting options for Control

Besides privacy and stress, control over the birthing environment plays an important role in your comfort and well-being.

Control of the Home Environment

At home, you are in control of your birthing environment. You can fully customise the space to your liking, providing a sense of control and comfort. This contributes to a pleasant birthing experience.

Here are some aspects you can control at home:

Temperature: Set the thermostat to a comfortable 20-22°C.
Lighting: Choose between bright light or ambient lighting.
Furnishing: Place the bed, delivery bath or other furniture exactly the way you want it.
Personal items: Think photos, pillows, blankets or other familiar items.

Hospital restrictions

In a hospital, the flexibility to customise the environment is often limited. The standard set-up is mainly functional, which leaves less room for personal adjustments.

Some hospital restrictions:

Fixed arrangement: Beds and medical equipment are usually fixed.
Lighting: Limited dimming options and often bright fluorescent light.
Climate control: Central air conditioning, usually not individually adjustable.
Decoration: Fewer opportunities to personalise the space.

Comparison table Environmental control

Aspect	Home birth	Hospital birth
Temperature	Self-adjustable	Limited adjustable
Lighting	Full choice	Standard fluorescent lighting
Furniture	Flexible to move	Fixed arrangement
Personal items	Unlimited availability	Limited to small items
Moodmakers	Candles, music, photos possible	Usually only music allowed
Window ventilation	As you wish	According to hospital policy
Colour use	Own interior	Neutral hospital colours
Movement space	Entire house available	Restricted to room or ward

How much control you have over your environment can make a big difference in how comfortable you feel during labour. At home, you can customise almost everything to your preferences, while in hospital you are often bound by the standard facilities and rules.

Conclusion

Key Points

When choosing between home or hospital birth, peace and privacy play a major role. Our previous analyses show how important the environment during childbirth is for these aspects.

Key differences:

Aspect	Home birth	Hospital birth
Privacy	Control who is there	Changing caregivers and presence of other patients
Rest	Own, familiar surroundings	Regularly interrupted by hospital activities
Environmental control	Ability to customise space and atmosphere	Limited customisation options
Comfort	Use of private bed and bathroom	Standard hospital facilities

Follow-up steps

Use this information to take the next steps:

Discuss your preferences and expectations with your midwife.
Attend an information session on possible delivery locations.
Plan a tour of the hospital to experience the atmosphere.
Draw up a birth plan that clearly states your wishes.
Consult a practice like Midwifery House Sweet Life for personalised advice.

Every pregnancy is different. The best choice depends on your situation and preferences. Good preparation will give you the security to choose a place that suits you.